I adored the movie Shakespeare in Love. I loved the imaginative way the writers showed Will’s writing process, including the part about titling a Work In Progress. And, you have to agree, a title is important. I’m sure Romeo and Ethel, I mean Juliet, would agree.
Which brings me to the crux of my blog. Today is “Titling Tuesday” at Harlequin Superromance. The editorial staff is currently hard at work determining the titles for the six Superromance releases for the month of May 2011. Each brings to the table a list of suggested titles offered by the author, their individual “gut” instinct, years of experience, and, if none of that works, they can shake the Magic-8 ball.
Kidding.
Actually, I have no idea how a certain title is decided upon. I used to agonize for days over my list of title suggestions. I’ve been known to stew and fret and fret and stew. I’ve even asked my 7- and 4-year old granddaughters for help. (Insert gratuitious photo of said granddaughters.)

Shameless grandmotherly bragging.
But, back to the topic at hand.
Since my days of frustrating and often futile attempts to produce an impressive, but ultimately useless, list of potential titles, I’ve calmed down a bit. Now, I start a list at the beginning of each book, and slowly add to it over the course of writing said book. Sometimes the list can be fairly long and off-the-wall. This time….not so much.
The working title of this book (the last book in the Spotlight on Sentinel Pass series) is “Remy’s story.” (We had to call it something for contract purposes, and, well, she is the heroine.)
My other titles? Arugh. You don’t know how difficult this is. I feel naked (wait, I already blogged about that). Okay, here goes:
LOST AND FOUND FAMILY
REMY, MY LOVE
THE OTHER TWIN’S SECRET
THAT DREAM GIRL
MIGHT-HAVE-BEEN DREAMS
HOME AT LAST
LOST AND FOUND DREAMS
AT LONG LAST HOME
A FAMILY FOR BIRDIE
WITH JONAS AT HER SIDE
WITH REMY AT HIS SIDE
IN REMY’S DREAM
See? I told you this was tough. Once your brain gets attached to a certain theme, it’s hard to get away from it. And, in my defense, I’m not a marketing person. These titles might fit my story, but how will the appear to a potential buyer? That’s where the editors and marketing staff work their magic.
My friend Susan Gable
also has a book in the May 2011 Superromance line-up. Here’s what Susan told me today on Facebook: “My original title: Semper Fi Guy. Title Victoria told me they’re submitting to the “vision” team – As Good as His Word.”
I, for one, think that’s a great title. But Susan is still struggling with it. Here’s her take on the matter:
I’ve got to STOP putting titles that I really like, that I really think reflect my book, onto my manuscripts as working titles. See, I tend to get too attached to them. Then, when I end up with a different title…well…it’s like a LOT of this process. There’s a grieving process. I have to mourn the loss of my “vision” of the book, the loss of “my” title for the story. I have to give myself time to warm up to the new title. For me, the title should be somehow woven into the fabric of the story. So it could mean changes in the actual book as well. Finding a place to “tuck” the new title in.
Hayden Hawkins book started with a working title of Semper Fi. Hayden’s a former Marine (former, not ex, because once a Marine, always a Marine) and the phrase has significance to the plotline and the heroine. The working title quickly morphed into Semper Fi Guy – because Hayden’s also always been known as Mr. Thirty Days – his relationships only ever last thirty days. I thought Semper Fi Guy was cute and catchy, and significant.
The possible new title after my editor’s meeting today is: As Good as His Word. What do you think about that? See, I can’t decide yet how I feel about it because…I’m still mourning the loss of Semper Fi Guy. I’m not objective yet. I’ve got to go through my steps of mourning before I can be objective about it.
I think my next manuscript will be submitted (and more importantly, anchored in my BRAIN!) as Hero’s Name Story. So, Hayden’s Story. Or possibly the heroine’s story. Maybe that will save me some grieving. LOL.
Still no word on mine, yet, but I promise to return with final verdict as soon as I know. Now, if you’ll excuse me, I’m going to kneel and light incense before the altar of the God of Titles.
Deb